“I’ve asked you a hundred times to clean your room!” you scream as your voice hits the pitch only frustrated parents feel they can. Your child stares at you blankly, and you think: Why won’t my kids hear me? If this all rings too familiar, you’re not alone. Indeed, millions of parents go through this same cycle of frustration daily.

The true message is that when kids won’t listen, it is often not because they are being overtly defiant or stubborn. The issue most often is our discipline style, not our children’s behavior.

Once you uncover what might be going wrong, you can finally break the cycle and create a more successful parenting style for your family.

Mistake #1 Threats and Ultimatums

One common discipline mistake parents make is to use threats and ultimatums. We’ve all been there: “If you don’t stop that now, then you’re grounded for a week!”, or “I’m giving you one last warning!”.

Here’s the problem with the use of threats like this: kids are taught very quickly that threats are often nothing. When we continue to threaten with consequences but don’t implement them as often as we should, children develop what psychologists refer to as “threat immunity.”

They just stop taking us seriously. Also, threats leave us in a reactive, emotional, self-controlling state where we’re more prone to say things that we feel bad about.

Why Threats Backfire?

When you depend on threats, lots of things take place at the same time:

They’ll push boundaries: If you threaten grounding for a week, and then only ground for two days, your child will realize that your words don’t match your actions.

Higher anxiety: When a child is constantly threatened, she develops stress responses that not only make it harder to listen but also make it more likely that he will resist.

Power struggles: The threat more often escalates rather than diffuses situations, creating an adversarial relationship rather than one where the two parties work together.

Replace threats with clear and predetermined consequences that you are truly willing to impose. For example, instead of telling people, “If you don’t put your shoes on right now, you’re going to regret it,” try saying: “I see you haven’t put your shoes on yet. We will be gone within two minutes.

If your shoes aren’t on when it’s time to go, you’ll have to wear yesterday’s socks as there won’t be time to find them.” Notice the difference? This technique is mild, focused, and rational. Your kid understands the natural consequence, so you eliminated the emotional threat from the equation.

This technique actually helps children understand the consequences of their choices.

Mistake #2:

Varying Enforcement of Rules. Maybe the greatest hindrance to successful discipline is inconsistency. You know the scenario: you allow your child to skip their chores because you are too tired one afternoon, and the next, you’ll get mad and say you’re doing something about it all the next day if they don’t do it. Or perhaps you mandate the “no screens before dinner” policy on weekdays and just throw in the towel when your child refuses to follow on Monday night, and don’t set rules like that on weekends, and fail to be responsible for doing those chores.

Inconsistency is literally one of the worst things you can do when you’re trying to train children to listen and listen to rules. Why? Because it teaches them that rules change, that rules are flexible, arbitrary, and even mood-dependent.

The Problem of Inconsistency

A child thrives on predictability. When rules are enforced sporadically, the kids put more energy into seeking out the pattern than the behavior that they want to embed into their brains. And more so, inconsistency leads to what is known as “intermittent reinforcement.” It encourages unwanted behaviors, making them more persistent rather than less. Think about it from a child’s perspective: If they know (or you have learned from me) that you let them know 7 times out of 10 times they ignore your request they turn off the tablet, keep going.” Why do you alter one aspect of behavior if it’s sometimes effective?

Building Consistency At Home

To achieve a level of consistency, this guide says:

Defend your non-negotiables:

What are the most important rules on your family’s agenda?

It really doesn’t need to be all fight or flight.

• Follow the main rules you have chosen: Choose three or five core rules, and agree to enforce them at all times.
• Include your children: Share the reason these rules exist. “Our family rule is that we use kind words ‘cause everybody wants to feel respected in our place.’
• Set predictable consequences: A rule of law, everyone should know what could happen when a rule is broken in a family. Make a simple chart if necessary, especially for visual learners.
• Ensure that you stick to the consequences: Even when you’re exhausted, even when it might be easier to just let it slide, stick to the consequences. This is what credibility looks like.
• Give grace for growth: consistency doesn’t mean inflexibility. You can be consistent about rules yet still be flexible about minor infractions or circumstances (such as a sick child or an unusually difficult day).

Mistake #3: Lecture instead of listening

Here’s that bitter truth many parents need to hear: we don’t do long talks, and yet we do so every day. You’re familiar with the pattern that a few words won’t do; your children misbehave. Instead of talking, you go on a fifteen-minute lecture to summarize what he has said: Respect, responsibility, disappointment.

What? Your mind can never be with you in there, only in the moment, and your child’s eyes dart out at you. Lectures miss the mark and why. You lecture, and when we lecture, many things have taken place: We’re talking over the child’s internal processing (our brains shut down when we’re being talked at). It’s a survival tactic.

We neglect the real issue:

Often, there is a reason for misbehavior. Your child may not have listened because he did not understand the direction given or was too busy to comply. A lecture doesn’t explain those underlying causes. We destroy the relationship: Lecturing puts us in the worst, more superior, “I am right, and you are wrong” position than a collaborative problem-solving perspective.

The Listen-First Approach:

Rather than leading into a lecture, try something akin to the listen first approach:

• First, accept without judgment what you just read: “I saw that you hit your brother. Tell me what happened.”
• Second, actually listen to their reaction. No interrupting or preparing your rebuttal. Your child could say his or her brother took a toy and he or she felt frustrated, or they might tell you they feel overwhelmed about a test coming up.
• Third, validate how they are feeling (not necessarily how they are acting): “I heard that you were really frustrated. It’s okay to feel frustrated.” Lastly, steer them to a new solution: “Hitting is not how we deal with frustration in this household. What will you do differently next time?” This whole conversation might just take five minutes, not twenty, and best yet, your child actually learned something! They have also felt a sense of being heard, which in fact makes them a lot more likely to listen to you in the future, in a paradoxical way.

Mistake #4: Not Teaching, Just Punishing

There is an important distinction between punishment and discipline, yet many parents confuse the two. Punishment is a means of causing pain or discomfort to discourage behavior, and discipline is an attempt to educate and lead.

And, when we punish, such as by sending a child to a room without providing an explanation, withholding privileges that might create a connection, or using shame as a weapon, we can temporarily prevent the unwanted behavior. But we’re not really teaching our children how to behave better next time.

The punishment trap

Punishment often can result in:

A parent-child relationship breeds resentment. Children who are punished build up bitterness for their parents rather than internalize virtues about good behavior.

Sneakiness: Instead of learning from or altering the behavior of the kids, they simply get better at hiding it.

Incentive-based behaviour loss and internalisation of moral failure: Kids no longer have intrinsic motivation: They no longer want to go straight; they do it all for fear of retribution.

Destructive self-esteem: Repeated punishment can make children feel bad about themselves rather than believe they made a bad choice.

Teaching-Based Discipline:

When your child misbehaves, consider: “What does my child need to learn from this situation?” Then create a consequence that teaches that lesson. For example:

If they’ve been bad to a sibling, perhaps they need to help set things right or do something nice for that sibling, imparting empathy and repair. If they have failed something by being careless about it, then this might need to be part of helping to change something, helping develop responsibility, a lesson on responsibility, and that which is consequence for breaking it.

If they lied about completing the homework, they may need to do it under your supervision and talk to you about why integrity is important, a lesson in integrity. This method is a little slower to put in at first, but you’re altering your child’s approach to rules and responsibility in a major way.

Mistake #5: Ignoring Your Own Emotions and Triggers

Here’s something most parenting 101 articles don’t tell you: the reason your kids won’t listen frequently has more to do with your emotional state than they do with theirs. We normally work off our reactive brain instead of our rational brain when we are angry, tired, or overwhelmed, or triggered by our child’s behavior. We yell, we overreact, and we say things that escalate the situation.

Above all, our children start looking at our emotional state rather than their own behavior.

Understanding Your Triggers

All parents have their own triggers and particular behaviors or situations that set them off within seconds. Maybe it’s when your child won’t listen after you’ve repeatedly asked. Maybe it’s whining that causes you to long to crawl out of your skin. Or maybe it’s disrespect that sends you into a rage.

These triggers are those that echo our own childhood, our immediate distress (or lack thereof), or unfulfilled needs. Until we confront them, they will only continue undermining our discipline efforts. Shifting the way you discipline your children is arguably one of the most important things you can do as a parent to make the most productive decisions in order to help make a parent.

When you change from punishing to teaching, threatening punishment, threat to consequences, and lecture to listen, you aren’t just changing behavior; you are building a better relationship with your kids and teaching them some truly golden life skills. Plus, probably you’ll have less stress and frustration yourself. When discipline is less about a battle and more about collaboration, however, parenting becomes a more fun experience for all involved. Try just one strategy this week. Pick the mistake that makes the biggest impact on you and you will be willing to make the recommended alternative.

—

Have you struggled with any of these discipline mistakes? What’s worked for your family? I’d love to hear your story in the comments below. And if you found this helpful, consider subscribing to Mom Creative Blogger for more honest, practical parenting guidance delivered straight to your inbox.